Macaroni Pie Recipe

Home/Barbados Recipes/Macaroni Pie Recipe
One of the nations that have influenced the Caribbean cuisine is the closest, the USA. Referred to in many islands simply as “pie,” macaroni cheese is standard fare and always a winner, especially with children.

There are several variations of this dish. Adding 2-3 tablespoons of tomato ketchup or tomato salsa gives a nice orange color and added flavor.

You can use different kinds of pasta such as penne or rotini to make Barbadian-made Maraconi Pie. Adding two small tins of tuna is also an option and makes it more of a main course than a side dish.

You will need the following ingredients:

  • 8oz/250g macaroni(preferably long tubes as opposed to typical American macaroni)
  • One tablespoon butter or margarine
  • 12oz/375g sharp cheddar cheese, grated
  • 1 egg
  • 1 cup 8floz/240ml milk
  • Two teaspoons onion powder
  • One teaspoon hot English mustard
  • One teaspoon white pepper
  • One teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon red pepper sauce or cayenne pepper (optional)


  • Two tablespoons fine breadcrumbs
  • Two teaspoons butter
  • Two tablespoons grated cheddar cheese


Bring water to the boil and add the broken up macaroni or macaroni elbows and salt. Cook it uncovered until it is just tender but not overcooked (about 8 minutes).

Preheat a moderately hot oven 350F, 180C or Gas Mark 4.

Drain the macaroni thoroughly, put it back into the same hot saucepan it was cooked in, and mix in the butter.

Grate the cheese and mix it in with the macaroni a bit at a time, while it is still warm.

Whisk the egg until fluffy and add the milk, onion powder, white pepper, salt, pepper sauce, and mustard. Pour in with the macaroni and mix.

Place in a greased ovenproof casserole dish. Top with a little butter, some grated cheese, and fine breadcrumbs. Bake in the center of the oven for about 30-45 minutes, depending on the dish’s depth.

About Totally Barbados (Edit profile)

Brett Callaghan is the founder and managing director of Totally Barbados. I specialize in writing content for the tourism industry for my island home of Barbados. I help companies build strategies to grow their businesses online with SMART marketing, advertising, and social media goals.